Court directs the state to ratify and legislate the domestication of ICPED

A Busia High Court ordered the state to ratify and legislate the domestication of the International Convention for the Protection of All Persons from Enforced Disappearance (ICPED) following the abduction of a Busia businessman, Ahmed Ibrahim Mohamed.

Ahmed allegedly boarded a bus on January 26, 2026, from Busia to Nairobi but was allegedly abducted by state agencies.

The Busia High Court Judge, Samwel Mohochi, while delivering the judgment last week, issued the order following a petition filed by Busia Senator Okiya Omtatah and Ahmed’s uncle, Mohamed Garad Mohamed, who sued the state over the alleged abduction of Ahmed, whose whereabouts remained unknown.

The judge directed the Cabinet Secretary (CS) for Interior, Kipchumba Murkomen, and Attorney General (AG) Dorcas Oduor to submit the ICPED to the Cabinet for approval within 90 days and then transmit it to the relevant departmental committees of Parliament for consideration, ratification and legislative domestication.

“Taking judicial notice of the Senate Standing Committee report on enforced disappearances and the absence of a specific statutory framework criminalising enforced disappearances in Kenya, the CS Interior and AG are hereby directed to initiate the statutory process under the Treaty Making and Ratification,” Mohochi added.

Court orders state to ratify disappearance treaty

Okiya and Mohamed told the court that Ahmed, an electronics merchant, had boarded a bus at Busia heading to Nairobi but was allegedly abducted at a Korinda Prison roadblock in Busia County after police officers, the Anti-Terrorism Police Unit (ATPU) and the Kenya Revenue Authority (KRA) intercepted the vehicle he had boarded.

The court heard that Ahmed was carrying USD 130,000 for trade operations, and the petitioners demanded that the state security chiefs be compelled to produce him in court immediately.

Justice Mohochi regretted that nearly two decades ago, Kenya signed the ICPED, yet the country has still not ratified or domesticated it into national law.

“Enforced disappearance is a continuous, agonising violation of Articles 25(a), 28, 29, and 49. The Constitution of Kenya does not permit citizens to vanish into thin air, nor does it tolerate unacknowledged, secret detentions. This Court will not issue orders in vain, nor will it allow the state to escape public accountability,” Mohochi noted.

Okiya and Mohamed had sued the Inspector General (IG) of the National Police Service, Douglas Kanja; the Director of Criminal Investigations (DCI), Mohamed Amin; the commander of the ATPU; the Director-General of the National Intelligence Service (NIS), Noordin Haji; the CS Interior, Murkomen; the Commissioner-General of the KRA; the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP), Renson Ingonga; the National Transport and Safety Authority (NTSA); and the AG, Oduor.

Okiya and Mohamed urged the court to summon Kanja, Amin, the ATPU commander and Haji to appear in court to account for the enforced disappearance, stating that the orders aimed to safeguard Ibrahim’s life, dignity, liberty and physical safety.

Okiya and Mohamed told the court that Ahmed’s disappearance was a pre-planned inside operation, citing evidence that a Buscar bus booking clerk, Mr Ashraf, placed a mysterious passenger on the bus with instructions to give a lift to an undercover field operative.

The duo said the spotter was later witnessed at the roadblock actively coordinating with the abductors in the getaway vehicle before alighting seamlessly at the subsequent roadblock.

The duo pointed to an intentional cover-up, highlighting that the official passenger manifest surrendered by the police listed every single passenger as yet to check in, despite the bus physically carrying 24 passengers.

Ahmed was allegedly singled out and interrogated, stripped of his personal effects and forcibly bundled into another vehicle. He was not booked at any police station and has never been presented before any court of law in Kenya.

Petitioners allege an organised operation

The state denied any involvement but confirmed that Ahmed had boarded a Buscar bus, which was flagged down near the Korinda Main Prison Stage by two women and two men operating a civilian black Volkswagen.

The state argued that the individuals boarded the bus, checked passengers’ identification documents, forced Ahmed into their car after a brief tussle and confiscated his greenish luggage bag.

The state asserted that Ahmed was abducted by criminals posing as police officers, arguing that the petition was based on mere conjecture and lacked direct evidence.

The state objected to the personal summoning of Kanja, Amin, the ATPU commander and Haji to account for the disappearance, maintaining that it was actively investigating the crime to rescue the abductee and that the officials bore no liability for the abduction.

Justice Mohochi observed that the DCI had completely ignored the prison as a primary source of eyewitness evidence, despite the bus conductor testifying that the entire operation occurred right at the main gate of Busia Main Prison.

“The fact that this complex, multi-stage extraction took significant time directly in front of an armed state facility, combined with the DCI’s deliberate failure to interview the prison guards or the bus driver, heavily undermines the state’s ‘imposter theory’. It provides this High Court with powerful circumstantial proof of state complicity, collusion, or an active cover-up,” Mohochi added.

The judge questioned how armed criminals could freely set up, control or seamlessly man a roadblock in front of a well-lit and fortified prison gate and proceed to remove a citizen from public transport without attracting intervention from prison authorities.

Court orders officials to produce Ahmed

The court ordered Kanja, Amin, Haji and the ATPU commander, jointly and severally, to produce Ahmed’s body, dead or alive, before the court within 48 hours and to issue a public apology within 14 days or convene a physical meeting with Mohamed and Ahmed’s immediate family at Police Headquarters.

The judge ordered the state to publish a formal public apology within 21 days, to be aired on at least two mainstream local radio stations within Busia County in both Kiswahili and the predominant local dialect, distancing itself from criminal acts.

The court urged Mohamed to formally prove the special financial loss of USD 130,000 pleaded in the further affidavit by attaching all verifiable documentary evidence of the funds and trade operations, together with brief written submissions, within 14 day.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *